Assessment in The Classroom
Standardized Testing. Two words that can instantly send any
educator into a frenzy. It’s no secret that standardized testing often receives
negative feedback from future and present educators of our youth. As this
chapter points out, there are more and more testing requirements being enforced
as the weeks go on. Something that really stuck out to me, was one of the
scenarios located on the first page of the chapter where Rosa and George were
given test questions and marked “incorrect” answers even though the answers
they gave seemed to be better fitting than the ones that were provided. The
only reason they were penalized was because their answers were different from
the experiences of the person who wrote the questions. This situation is more
common than you'd think and I find it extremely contradicting that throughout
children’s education we encourage them to learn using context clues and
experiences but we tear that skill away from them when we rely on standardized
testing to be the basis of our lessons. This scenario states that Rosa and
George are in the first and second grade when given this test and according to the stages
of Child Development on pages 56 & 57 their age groups are just then
mastering the skill of distinguishing between right from wrong. At seven &
eight they are realizing the difficulty and worrying that school might be too
hard, which is a very fragile realization that requires reassurance from their
teachers. One of the reasons this concerns me is because of the pressure that I
know standardized testing puts on children and teachers. Did anyone else have
this concern when they read this scenario? One of the qualities of being a
great educator is being aware of each students strengths, weaknesses, and
striving to help each child to reach their full potential through encouragement
and praise. I feel that because of the pressure that standardized testing puts
on the classroom, it is easy to get caught up on the focus of raising test
scores rather than teachers giving their full attention to each students
strengths and weaknesses.
However,
while I have such strong feelings on the negatives of standardized testing, I
am aware of the importance that assessing the students has on their growth.
This chapter opened my eyes to some creative and insightful ways that teachers
can access their students without overwhelming them. Using authentic assessment techniques in the
classroom was more appealing to me because of the diversity it has and could be
altered to benefit the needs of the student. Using videos and audio recording
would be a good way for students to motivate the students because it allows
them to see at first hand, what they are doing correctly/incorrectly. Having
conferences and checklists are also great ways to maintain routine and focus
throughout time periods that incorporate collaboration not only between teacher
and student, but also incorporation the students parents. Does anyone else
agree that these techniques could be beneficial to the classroom development?
Using Informal Inventories in the
classroom was another strategy that got my attention, specifically portfolio
assessment. To me, this seems like a great way to track student progress
throughout the year in a low-pressure way that can help the teacher and student
while motivating them. This strategy also would be useful to parents because it
updates them and allows them to have solid information of their child’s skills.
As I read this it sparked my mind to wonder what other low-pressure testing we
could incorporate into our classroom, does anyone else have any ideas of ways
we could do this? The further that I read in this chapter, the more that I
began to realize that testing can be done as long as it is monitored and
altered with each child’s development in mind.
Great post! I agree with just about everything you said. I agree that there is a reason that there is standardized testing and it can be helpful sometimes to see how students are doing but then there are other students that it just doesn't work for. So if only we could use some of those evaluations you talked about I feel like we could work with our students better, we as teachers would be less stressed and our students would be as well! I really think that your last point about the portfolio is a great idea. I really liked that idea when I was reading too. I think I would do it for every subject so every day after class they could write down what they really took away from that day and so before tests they could look back at their own words and work to refresh their memory! All together good post thanks for your ideas!
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed your blog and agreed with pretty much everything you said! The scenarios in the beginning stood out to me as well. Imagining first graders taking standardized tests just amazes me. The scenarios aren't surprising to me, especially George drawing a carrot in place of marking the correct answer. That is a logical answer to a first grader.
ReplyDeleteI also enjoyed how you discussed what makes a great educator. I completely agree. I want the focus in my classroom to be focusing on every child's individual strengths and helping them achieve their best.
In this chapter, I found it interesting to look at all the different types of assessments. Sometimes I think teachers just do the simple pencil and paper test because they find it easiest, but this book listing the different types is helpful. I think each type of assessment has its purpose though I agree that authentic assessment can be beneficial in the classroom.
Finally, the portfolio idea stuck out to me as well, but as a great tool to use in parent-teacher conferences. I think that it is important to save different types of assessment and work from a student to discuss with parents. It is especially helpful to have proof and reasons to back up your suggestions with a difficult parent.
Hey Lexi! I thought your blog post was really interesting, and I completely agreed with everything that you said. When I read the part about Rosa and George it made me upset because it was almost unfair to them as students. Rosa had a huge language barrier, which is why a standardized test like that is not an accurate way to assess her progress or what she understands. Additionally, it is never fair to test students who are so young! I couldn't have said it better myself. They aren't able to do multiple choice questions or differentiate answers by themselves. I also really liked the portfolio idea. I think thats a really good way for teachers as well as parents to see progress over the year.
ReplyDeleteI also found it interesting to read about all the different ways to assess the students without using standardized testing. I know personally I am not good at standardized testing and get very anxious about taking tests. It is really easy to feel stupid after failing a test like that which is probably for me where a lot of my anxiety comes from. That feeling of failing and feeling stupid. I think it is super important to use different methods of assessment so that students don't have all those anxieties about testing. I feel like having an assessment that doesn't say you failed out of this percent of your peers would be a better alternative.
ReplyDeleteI think that you were pretty spot on with everything that you said and your opinions reflect my own as well! I understand that there is a reason for standardized testing and to be honest I haven't totally given up on the idea of having it. I think it can be a very helpful tool, like many other forms of assessment, if used in the right way. Do you think that we should totally eliminate standardized testing? I also really liked your point about students looking to teachers for reassurance and if teachers have all of this stress and pressure laid on their shoulders about standardized testing, students might not feel as supported and may not be able to perform to the best of their ability. As another first reader discussed, the portfolio idea does sound like a great one, although I am a little concerned that it will start to take on the same dynamic as a standardized test. As a teacher, how do you plan to use the portfolios, while also making sure that the same anxiety students and teachers have about standardized testing doesn't carry over into the portfolio concept?
ReplyDelete